![](https://substackcdn.com/image/fetch/w_1456,c_limit,f_auto,q_auto:good,fl_progressive:steep/https%3A%2F%2Fsubstack-post-media.s3.amazonaws.com%2Fpublic%2Fimages%2Fefa805fc-3a51-413d-b17d-ae48d71c8948_587x334.jpeg)
NATO’s Seventy fifth-anniversary summit in Washington, celebrated in early July, was uncommon not solely due to the extraordinary longevity of the alliance but additionally due to the eye paid to ‘threats’ posed by powers i.e., China, from far exterior of its geographical focus in Europe. NATO chiefs indicted China for supporting Russia in Ukraine. However the Ukraine battle is anticipated to be solely a prelude to the alliance’s adventures exterior of Europe. The summit confirmed a deliberate growth of the alliance into Asia. A quote from the Washington-summit joint declaration says all of it:
“The Indo-Pacific is vital for NATO, on condition that developments in that area straight have an effect on Euro-Atlantic safety. We welcome the continued contributions of our Asia-Pacific companions to Euro-Atlantic safety. We’re strengthening dialogue to deal with cross-regional challenges … These tasks will improve our means to work collectively on shared safety pursuits.”
It is a main improve from NATO’s 2019 summit in London, during which the alliance’s officers described China, for the primary time, as a “problem.” In 2021, NATO as soon as once more known as China a “systematic problem” that wanted to be tackled collectively. In 2024, this ‘collectivity’ has been outlined when it comes to its rising ties with Asian international locations to counter the rising Russia-China-North Korea nexus, producing concern that this alliance will come to dominate the Asia-Pacific area. Though NATO will not be really in search of members from Asia, it has expressed its willingness to develop military-to-military cooperation with international locations corresponding to Japan and South Korea.
![](https://substackcdn.com/image/fetch/w_1456,c_limit,f_auto,q_auto:good,fl_progressive:steep/https%3A%2F%2Fsubstack-post-media.s3.amazonaws.com%2Fpublic%2Fimages%2F215a4fc6-318d-4883-bd5a-fd9eae5b98c1_1200x720.jpeg)
This expansionist coverage comes at a time when NATO can be dealing with bother at dwelling. Since February 2022, it has been (not directly) preventing Russia in Ukraine. Simply earlier than the Russia-Ukraine army battle started, there existed severe doubts about NATO’s viability in Europe. France’s Macron known as it “mind lifeless,” with the then-Trump administration within the US additionally pushing itself away over the truth that the US contributed greater than 60 p.c of the alliance’s finances. Whereas the Biden administration was in a position to underplay the importance of the US’s asymmetrical relationship, this situation is all set to develop into central ought to Donald Trump return to the US presidency. Can NATO survive a second Trump presidency, particularly with JD Vance, a robust critic of US help for Ukraine and NATO, as his working mate?
There are not any straightforward solutions but, however NATO is already attempting to ‘Trump-proof’ itself, together with by assembly with officers of the Trump marketing campaign to get a way of Trump’s overseas coverage priorities.
It’s my understanding that NATO’s ‘China indictment’ might be additionally a part of NATO’s unwritten and undeclared ‘Trump-proofing’ efforts. With Trump being a robust critic and opponent of China and because the initiator of the ‘commerce struggle’ on China as effectively, NATO’s rising deal with China may assist, from the alliance’s perspective, to retain (President) Trump’s curiosity within the alliance. In different phrases, the Trump administration may be prepared to maintain the US-NATO ties totally useful i.e., as they’re in the present day, if he may be satisfied that NATO has a future within the Asia-Pacific area towards China.
The truth is, NATO Secretary Normal Jens Stoltenberg’s latest article in International Affairs may be learn as an effort to maintain NATO sturdy to face what he described as an “more and more harmful world” being common by the Russia-China alliance. Will Trump and Vance take heed to him? There are solely unsure solutions.
However this isn’t the one situation worrying NATO. Extra importantly, will international locations within the Asia-Pacific area additionally endorse its new mission towards Russia and China, and bounce on the bandwagon of transatlantic safety that, as a substitute of discovering new members, will make its presence seen and potent by rising coordination alongside protection traces? In brief, will international locations within the Asia-Pacific area be prepared to ‘NATOize’ their protection and overseas insurance policies?
For one factor, NATO’s prospects in Asia are significantly undermined by the greater than sturdy chance of Trump’s victory in November. Will we see the identical enthusiasm within the pro-US Asia-Pacific capitals Tokyo, Seoul, and Canberra, that we see in the present day if and when NATO skeptics and critics assume energy? Earlier than the Washington summit, South Korean President Yoon Suk-yeol’s principal deputy nationwide safety adviser, Kim Tae-hyo, informed reporters that the president will carry to Washington “a robust message relating to the army cooperation between Russia and North Korea and talk about methods to boost cooperation amongst NATO allies and Indo-Pacific companions”.
Nonetheless, there are numerous states within the area which might be removed from enthusiastic. The area additionally consists of states like India and Indonesia that also take delight within the Chilly Struggle period ‘Non-Alignment Motion’ (NAM). When India’s Modi lately visited Russia, he took all doable steps that may very well be anticipated at this stage to additional Russia’s agenda of a multipolar world order. Aside from reinforcing the settlement of bilateral commerce funds in nationwide currencies, Modi additionally confirmed his participation within the upcoming BRICS summit in Kazan, Russia in October.
Indonesia’s Prabowo can be reported to have rejected the “Chilly Struggle mentality,” and the Philippines’ Marcos, regardless of his nation’s well-known army ties with the US, thinks that “we’re decided as a gaggle in ASEAN and within the Indo-Pacific, these across the Indo-Pacific, regardless of all of this battle we’re decided to keep away from” the “Chilly Struggle kind of state of affairs the place you need to select one aspect or the opposite.”
A extra correct description of those international locations’ coverage appears to be restricted to utilizing their protection with the US, moderately than NATO, to counterbalance China. There isn’t a need to de-couple from China given vital and rising commerce ties. But, as a result of Washington repeatedly frames its insurance policies in direction of Beijing when it comes to everlasting de-coupling, it permits China to really body the US and the West because the aggressor. Proper after the Washington summit, a spokesperson for Beijing’s mission to the European Union stated NATO ought to “cease hyping up the so-called China menace and frightening confrontation and rivalry, and do extra to contribute to world peace and stability.”
This counter-narrative appears to have discovered a big place within the area. A 2024 Pew survey discovered {that a} median of 61 p.c throughout 10 Asia-Pacific international locations say China contributes to international peace and stability an incredible deal or a good quantity. This optimistic view can be tied to China’s deep financial ties with international locations on this a part of the world.
Due to this fact, even when NATO can by some means survive the Trump-Vance duo, it doesn’t have a vivid future. Given the depth of China’s financial presence, NATO is handicapped by the conspicuous absence of any comparable Western program of financial connectivity and commerce. Nonetheless, a Trump presidency would favor ‘financial nationalism’ and safety over multilateralism and open markets with little to no tariffs. China, subsequently, is unworried in the intervening time.
Dr Salman Rafi Sheikh is an Assistant Professor of Politics on the Lahore College of Administration Sciences (LUMS) in Pakistan. He’s a long-time contributor to Asia Sentinel